Skip to content

How Mitu Fought For Her Daughters’ Lives

December 15, 2009

How Mitu Fought For Her Daughters’ Lives – by Shobha S.V.

Life for Dr Mitu Khurana, 32, has not been easy. One of the few women in India who has raised her voice against female feticide, she not only indicted her in-laws and her husband but also the hospital concerned, under the Preconception and Pre Natal Diagnostic and Testing (PC&PNDT) Act, 1994.

The Delhi Commission for Women (DCW) has finally decided to look into the case that grabbed the attention of the media and the nation. Her repeated complaints to the District and State Appropriate Authority (a body where complaints in violation to the PC&PNDT Act can be filed) continue to remain unheeded. And now that she has not received a reply to her complaint from the State Appropriate Authority, she has approached the Central Appropriate Authority.

Mitu got married to Dr Kamal Khurana in 2004. The very next year, she conceived twins. Mitu claims that her in-laws and husband, in collusion with the hospital authorities, deceived her into getting an ultrasound test done. “They gave me a cake to eat despite knowing that I am allergic to egg. I started having pain in the abdomen, nausea and vomiting. The next day I was taken to the Jaipur Golden Hospital (a prominent facility in North West Delhi) where the doctor asked me to get a kidney ureter bladder ultrasound. They got the test done by deception. I was heavily sedated and did not realize what was happening,” she alleges. Subsequently, she says, her life became a living hell, as her in-laws started pressurizing her to get an abortion done because they did not want girls. Finally, tired of the harassment, she decided to go back to her parental home.

It’s been more than five months since she filed a complaint but no proper action has been taken so far. Mitu filed a complaint in April this year with the Chief District Medical Officer, North West Delhi. When that led to no action, she filed an application under Right to Information Act 2005. She, subsequently, got a reply stating that a raid was conducted at the Jaipur Golden Hospital and that no ‘Form F’ was found. According to the PC&PNDT Act, it is through Form F that the mandatory record is maintained by every genetic clinic, with respect to each woman subjected to any pre-natal diagnostic procedure.

Meanwhile, the PC&PNDT authorities continue to pass the buck. Dr A.K. Jaina, of the State Appropriate Appellate Authority, New Delhi says, “This case comes under the purview of the district appropriate authority. We cannot do much.” There is talk of getting the case transferred – it was filed under the PC&PNDT Act, which comes under the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare – to the Women and Child Ministry. However, the status of that initiative is also not known.

Mitu’s case has received support from all over India. Professor Bijay Laxmi Nanda, who teaches at Miranda House, Delhi University, and is coordinator, Campaign Against Female Feticide, says, “Her case is very unique. She’s one of the few women I am aware of who has managed to save both her daughters and now filed a case against her in-laws and the hospital.” Many women’s activists including ’50 million missing girls’, a group fighting against female feticide, have extended their support to Mitu.
Renny Jacob, Member, DCW, says, “Our lawyers are going through the documents. DCW has sent a letter to the Chief Medical Officer of the State Appropriate Authority. We are waiting for his response.” She adds, “Mitu has not got justice till date. The doctors and the hospital concerned should be punished. We are not interested in her issues of marital discord. However, we would like to see that justice is given to her.” According to Jacob, the medical fraternity usually observes a code of silence in cases like these. “Doctors usually don’t go against the doctors,” she says.

Mitu’s case holds a mirror to a fact quite evident in Delhi: it has one of the lowest female sex ratios in the country. According to a recent survey by Centre for Social Research, a Delhi-based non-governmental organization, the male-female sex ratio in areas of the Capital like Punjabi Bagh (West Delhi) and Najafgarh (South West Delhi) has plumbed new depths and the girl child is virtually shunned.

The PC&PNDT authorities have cited several reasons for the difficulties in the implementation of the Act. According to the 2006 annual report by the authorities, the collusion between the people demanding the illegal service of sex determination and the service providers is so strong that it is difficult to pin down the offender.

Right now Mitu stays with her parents who are also supporting her financially. “I am able to fight this battle only because of my parents. This can happen to anyone. I am a doctor from an educated family. If I can go through such an experience, anyone can.” When contacted, Mitu’s husband, Kamal, had only this to say, “Our case is in the Tis Hazari mediation centre. I do not wish to comment.”

According to the law, sex determination is banned under the PC&PNDT Act. Medical practitioners and gynecologists conducting the test and aborting the female fetus can be prosecuted under this Act and the offence is non-bailable. The law may be stringent, but when enforcers continue to look the other way, it makes very little difference.

October 5, 2008

No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: